Saturday, April 07, 2012

Wii U less powerful than Xbox360 and PS3?

Nintendo’s next generation console, the Wii U, may not even be on par with the hardware power of the company’s current-gen competitors, the Xbox360 and the PS3, according to some developers. In the meantime, president of Gearbox Software, Randy Pitchford, has praised the Wii U as “a really nice bridge to the next generation.” The four anonymous developers critical of the system are said to have access to development kits and have spoken anonymously to GamesIndustry.

"No, it's not up to the same level as the PS3 or the 360. (…) The graphics are just not as powerful."(…) "Yeah, that's true. It doesn't produce graphics as well as the PS3 or the 360. (…) There aren't as many shaders, it's not as capable. Sure, some things are better, mostly as a result of it being a more modern design. But overall the Wii U just can't quite keep up."

Two other sources questioned whether the Wii U’s tablet controller would be the big innovation Nintendo is hoping it will be and whether a combination of PS3 and PlayStation Vita may not be the better choice, offering a similar hardware setup.

"You can do everything with that combo that you can with the Wii U, and more." (…) "The whole thing about the tablet controller is that you only get one of them, and you can only use one and it's not completely independent. (…) The base console has to be on, and you have to be in range. (…) Other controllers are just Wiimotes, or other Wii controllers. They may change the form factor or looks a bit, but it's the same controller."

Randy Pitchford, president of Gearbox Software, praised the platform in an interview with Joystiq. After all, his studio is developing ´Aliens: Colonial Marines´ for the Wii U.

"I think it's a great platform and I'm really excited about it, particularly with this game, there's a lot of exciting opportunities like, 'Wow, my motion tracker is there, and I can move it like this!' (…) There's just so much cool stuff. (…) There's a lot that we can do with that screen (…) It's a really cool system -- it's pretty powerful. I want to be careful, because I don't want to risk any sensitive information that Nintendo's not ready to share yet, but in our experience it's a great system. I think it's a really nice bridge to the next generation.”

It is interesting to note that he refused to call the Wii U a next generation system. This may tie in with the anonymous comments above. However, Pitchford seemed to suggest that Nintendo had yet to announce what the Wii U is capable of and repeated that point.

"Nintendo still has a lot to announce with their platform, and it's not up to us to go ahead of them. (…) I think people will be surprised. I don't know off the top of my head how many of the specs they've released, so I want to be very careful not to jump the gun, but we're very pleased with the hardware. And even since they gave us our first alpha kit, our very first 'pre-prototype' development hardware that they kind of let us play around with, they've done so many things to make the platform better. So it's getting better for us as developers."

These comments are reminiscent of the Wii’s long-rumoured last secret, a surprising feature the Wii was supposed to possess. However, no such secret ever materialised. The rumours were either wrong or the last secret was canned at the last minute, similarly to the Gamecube’s proprietary 3D-screen.

So, will the Wii U outshine Xbox360 and PS3 or not? Remember that I was able to bring you the exclusive news that the Wii would be significantly underpowered compared to the competition. And already with the Gamecube from the previous hardware generation, Nintendo seemed to have withdrawn from the race for hardware power, leaving the most powerful console to Microsoft and its Xbox. But, in my mind, no console has ever offered less power than the previous generation and such a scenario is hardly likely. Xbox360 and PS3 are six years old and the bill of materials for their hardware components must have come down to less than $100. So can we not assume that the Wii U must be a more powerful machine? Is it not obvious? The first Wii U hands-on impressions seemed to suggest so.

The answer may lie in the console’s tablet controller and pricing. The tablet controller may turn out to be the most expensive component and Nintendo may again aim for a low price point. In fact, I was able to reveal that Nintendo considered selling the Wii for a mere $100, a fact that was later confirmed by Miyamoto himself. Should Nintendo really want to implement such a strategy with the Wii U, the hardware could only be a small step up from the Wii. Technologies like cloud gaming may become a threat in the future and other devices such as smartphones and tablets are said to be already eating into the market share of traditional consoles. Overstated as this point may be, the GamesIndustry article points out that the retail market for console hardware and software has fallen by eight percent last year in both the US and Japan. So Nintendo may be well advised to launch the Wii U at a bargain price.

Or does Nintendo simply believe that Microsoft and Sony will not be able to release new consoles before 2014 at the earliest? This strategy appears riskier, but there is certainly reason to believe that the competition will want to drag out the lifecycle of their current hardware. After all, both companies have poured billions into their console divisions and, in the absence of recent numbers, both consoles still cannot be anywhere near profitability. This is a point usually ignored by gamers and industry observers alike. The key factors to a console’s success are hardware sales, the software to hardware tie ratio and the profitability of the hardware. In the last generation, for example, Nintendo is widely believed to have been the big loser. But the Gamecube brought in money from day one. It sold almost as many units as the Xbox, which at least initially was heavily subsidized. So Nintendo made money while the original Xbox left Microsoft a few billion Dollars short.

So, while industry analysts see ”increasingly problematic structural problems” for the Wii U, it is important to bear in mind that Nintendo have relatively little to worry about. They have almost always been able to push their consoles into profitable territory. And they own the biggest gaming franchises in the world. The Wii U may not become the hardware beast the next PlayStation and Xbox may become, but will that matter? After all, the Wii is clearly the runaway success and winner of this generation. And, in my mind, should the Wii U really not be capable of outperforming both Xbox360 and PS3, a price point of between $100 and $150 will have to make up for that.


EDIT Website Forget The Box has added details to the Wii U Hardware, citing anonymous Nintendo sources. The bill of materials is said to come to around $180 in total, $50 of which make up the tablet controller. Nintendo is apparently considering a launch price of "no less than $300."

According to our sources: “Cutting production costs to maximize profits is Nintendo’s main concern with the Wii U. They are cutting costs in the Wii U’s hardware to build back confidence in investors. Nintendo wants investors to view Wii U as a less risky proposition. ”

The new NFC capabilities for each new Wii U controller costs no more than $5 to implement, and the prices of NFC implementation in mobile devices is expected to fall below $1 in the near future. Our source explained: “NFC capabilities are a drop in the bucket for Nintendo. As NFC becomes more mainstream in mobile devices, the price for NFC implementation will rapidly decline. Nintendo is jumping on NFC because of a projected cost decline in the technology.”

When we asked about the controller’s other manufacturing costs:

“The cameras in the Wii U controller are an estimated manufacturing cost of $6. They are slightly better quality than the 3DS and DSi cameras. The touch screen has a manufacturing cost estimated at $14.” (...)

“Nintendo chose an economical GPU and CPU that could keep up with the performance of today’s current consoles, but keep hardware costs down to maximize profits. Nintendo got a bargain price on the custom GPU and CPU that the Wii U uses. There is a bigger focus on downloadable content, applications, video content, digital distribution, and services to create a stream of revenue. Investors will be ecstatic with the news.”

While the website is unknown to me, they do report about the videogame industry regularly. Only in January, Forget The Box reported about the Wii U's alleged eReader functionality. This does not necessarily make the website more credible, but may be an indication of the authors having genuine inside sources. The rumours certainly tie in with the above statements about the console. If true, a bill of materials around $130 for the console by itself would suggest modest hardware power. But it would certainly suggest that the console is more powerful than the Xbox360 and the PS3.

EDIT Tech video blogger Richard Masucci from ReviewTechUSA has posted an elaborate run-down of the known Wii U tech specs, comparing them with the Xbox360 and PS3 (thanks, Anonymous). In it, he concludes that the above rumours by anonymous developers are "a big pile of crap", pointing among other things to the Wii U's multithreading ability and generous L3 cache. The Wii U CPU will be able to "handle 16 threads of code simultaneously", while the Xbox360 and PS3 can only handle six. Masucci concludes:


"Even if the Wii U only uses the entry level quad-core Power 7 processor, its capabilities destroy the Cell processor hands-down. (...) It would be a moronic business move and almost impossible for Nintendo to make the Wii U less powerful than the current generation consoles. I mean, hell, if Nintendo went to nVidia and asked them to use the 8800 GT which is now a five year old GPU, it would still blow away the graphics processors that are in the Xbox360 and PlayStation3 - and it's five years old and costs next to nothing now."

In another video, Masucci compares the Wii U tech specs with what is known about the PlayStation4. Even here, the Wii U measures up, provided that Sony puts something along the lines of an AMD Radeon HD 7670 in the console, Masucci says. Should Sony go all out on the PS4 and use an AMD Radeon HD 7950 with Nintendo choosing a 4850 or 4770 as the Wii U's GPU, Nintendo will be left behind in terms of graphics power pretty much the way they are in the current generation. However, bear in mind that the Vita has not been a great step up from the PSP and that Sony is in dire financial trouble right now. They might not have the muscle to put out another PlayStation3. And remember the lessons learned from releasing such a costly hardware beast.

16 comments:

Anonymous said...

Hi Falafelkid, nice article thus Time . For me its always funny to See how analysts give their comments about a console which is Even Not on the market and they haven t Play with it. And i think Nintendo is Not crazy to Show all they have to Public and competitioner over One year before lunch. So its a fact that they have some Big surprise left for the next E3! Nintendo themselves Said that they showed only 10 % , thats nothing! I would not be surprised if the Controller Displays 3D in an better Way then the 3ds does and if it has tacticle feedback rumorend in the Last days... best regards Sebastian

Spazer said...

Hello Falafel,
This is clear that those third parties who speak about the Wii U's power only have the first dev kits or are telling bullshit. We already know from french insiders that the console is a minimum of 2 Xbox 360 duct taped together, regarding the kits V4 and V5. We know that the Wii U is tweaked a lot to run Unreal Engine 4 (maybe a lighter version). This is obvious that Nintendo can't release a new conole less powefull than ps360, this is suicide. For sure it will not be a beast, as probably playstation Orbis and Durango, but something like a pretty powerful machine as said recently from a Darksiders 2 developer.

Anonymous said...

Nintendo is playing it smart from a financial perspective. By having a system "on par" with the xbox360, they can release the system relatively cheap, between $250-300. (there is no way they are releasing it for under $250). If the tablet gimmick moves units, as the wiimote did 6 years ago, they'll make a ton of money. If it doesn't sell well, they can drop the price quickly like they did with the 3ds, but unlike the 3ds, it will still make money. Given the anemic wii sales the last two years, Nintendo probably wishes the wii u would have been ready for release in 2010 or 2011. With a one year head start on ps4 and xbox720, they'll be well positioned to release the next gen machine in 4-5 years.

Anonymous said...

Wii-U Hardware Specs Explained

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OcnsG11MRE8

Spazer said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Anonymous said...

to vibe with sb. [Am.] [sl.]:
die gleiche Wellenlänge haben,
mit jdm. auf der gleichen Wellenlänge funken / liegen

Grandmaster B said...

Mark Rein even praised the Wii U....enough said really. He bags Nintendo all of the time and the fact he is praising it it a positive. He would just be saying the same as the others otherwise.

Of course this isnt the be all and end all.

Anonymous said...

LOL @ THIS BLOG AS PER USUAL !!!!!!

yto even consider that wiiu is as powerful or less than x360 is so insane FANBOYISM its not even funny you really are a prize plumb your anti nintendo nonsense is clear for all to see

AT BARE BONES MINIMUM it will be like x360 ps3 and wii combined i mean to even suggest such out right bollox makes you look a complete derp


stop drinking and serving anti nintendo cool aid you sad idiot

Anonymous said...

a 45nm system on chip in 2012 will cost vastly less than a ps3 chip set and also blow it away THATS COMMONSENSE

if its a 4870 like gpu with junk removed going system on chip and shrinking to 45nm you could probably decrease size by about 60/70% as well as heat and power consumption

that is common sense also IBM EDRAM Takes up 1/3 the area of sram so 96mb fits in the area of 32mb sram

so in fact based on reality not anti nintendo cool aid drinking and herp derp its clear nintendo could have a system with say 1.6ghz cpus and a 800mhz gpu loads of edram and a fast main ram


that utterly shits on ps3 and x360 combined

Anonymous said...

@ 45nm you can fit 4 broadway cpus in the same area as 1 broadway cpu in wii and also run them at 1.6 ghz to say 2.4ghz and use no more power or heat than wiis cpu did

also they now run at 5 instruction per clock vs 2 instructions per clock that wiis cpu did

easy 12 to 20 x the power of wiis cpu add a arm co-cpu and a sound processor presto a amazing cpu and co-processing chip set

all you need now is edram and a cool gpu

this blog sucks ass

Anonymous said...

didnt gearbox say the complete opposite stating clearly more powerful than ps3 x360

funny how people like you hang on to rumor from no one not facts from someone PATHETIC BLOGGING

Anonymous said...

after gearbox stating that its next gen for the past year and stating so again in the latest aliens interview trailer and again confirming wiiu to 1 be next gen 2 to be the best looking console version 3 to have things impossible on ps3 and x360 and again confirming more gpu ram etc

everything you sem obsessed with is a fraud !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Anonymous said...

http://geek.pikimal.com/2012/06/08/the-wii-u-will-have-8gb-internal-memory1-5gb-ram-and-other-fun/

Based on this link, the reviewtechusa video overstates the wii u's graphics. Looks like a marginal improvement over the ps3 and xbox 360.

Ian bell said...

I absolutely feel ecstatic when I find articles relevant to my work and my subject.
ps3

Anonymous said...

yto perhaps Buy rs goldconsider that wiiu is as strong as well as less than x360 is very insane FANBOYISM it's just not possibly humorous you really are any reward plumb the stop designers spam you can see for
Cheapest Diablo 3 gold all to find out

Chinese Dress said...

Nonetheless, the usage of trousers was found to become very first recorded in the 6th Century B.C. by ancient Greeks.